The survey was intended for people who are concerned about the replacement of sex by gender identity in public policy and institutions (i.e. “gender critical” people). Many also raised the human rights of people who identify as transgender.
The intention of this survey was not to silence anyone, but nor was it asking for debate. Some people chose to respond with dissenting views to the purpose of the survey; some thoughtful and some puerile.
These dissenting voices are included here.
Because I’m a middle class, middle aged white woman with no real problems
Because I’m a middle class, middle aged white woman with no real problems and I desperately need someone to lash out at Been a massive fucking pain in the arse on social media and Mumsnet and real life Yes, many people rightfully see right through my nonsense and call me on it. On the plus…
It scares me that GC feminists cannot see the consequences of supporting what is a far right/fascist stance
So much of Gender Critical/radical feminism, forces women into boxes and denies them the fullness of their gender expression. trans exclusion derides women who enjoy makeup (“woman face”), and also for wearing jeans and t-shirts (“not trying hard enough”). It also threatens women’s bodily autonomy and it scares me that GC feminists cannot see the…
Spreading hatred against a minority group is not only illegal, but totally anti-feminist
This matters to me because spreading hatred against a minority group is not only illegal, but totally anti-feminist. I care because I want all people to be protected and have equal access to appropriate spaces. I speak out because I will not stand by and watch adults harm trans children. I have donated to LGBTQ+…
I’m on the right side of history and those whose insides aren’t rotted by bigotry can see the benefit
This matters to me because Trans rights are human rights. Ours trans siblings are currently the victims of an egregious smear campaign from the same sources who tried and failed to hold back others in the queer community. The arguments being made by TERFs and gender critical individuals are dog whistles designed to hide their…
This matters to me because trans women are women
This matters to me because trans women are women. The vile bigoted attacks on women for being trans are offensive to me as a feminist. As an abortion rights activist, I’m offended by the anti-trans activists who want to specify in law that abortions are for women only, thus ensuring trans men who need abortions…
Transphobia is a hate crime
Transphobia is a hate crime. I use every platform available to spread the message that transphobia is a hate crime. I’ve been verbally and physically assaulted by TERFs (no, it’s not a slur). Imagine being so full of hate for people like me who are fighting for their basic human rights to exist that you’d…
Biology, psychology, and sociology are all in favour of trans people
I care because transgender individuals deserve the right to live as any other human being. They are born human, and bleed red just like everyone else. They do not need transphobes making their life worse because of “basic” biology, because if a transphobe actually cared enough to research, they’d find biology, psychology, and sociology are…
Female female female
As a female woman I care because of my own personal experiences. When I was 25 I became close personal friends with a person calling themselves Emily. We shared all our experiences and secrets together. However one day we were sitting together in the sun enjoying Prosecco when I saw on her arm a single…
I have spoken out against opinions and beliefs that Judge James Taylor ruled are not worthy of respect
I care because my opinions and beliefs are worthy on respect in a democratic society. I have spoken out against opinions and beliefs that Judge James Taylor ruled are not worthy of respect in a democratic society. I have received abuse and harassment from those who hold beliefs and opinions that are not worthy of…
Because y’all backwards af white feminists are making life harder for the most vulnerable people in our society
Why I care – Because y’all backwards af white feminists are making life harder for the most vulnerable people in our society. What action have you taken? This. Have you experienced any consequences? Probably Loki, You are nuts, USA
I have written articles from the Daily Telegraph and even a book
I care about this issue because trans rights are important. Back in the 90s trans people had very few rights even in employment until P v S and Cornwall Country Council ruled that you couldn’t discriminate against trans people, then later the ECHR in 2002 ruled that not allowing trans people to be legally recognised…
I have come out at work as a trans man
Quite simply, I care about all people being treated with respect. I care about the facts being shared, children brought up to be free to make their own choices, and adults able to access public spaces without fear. I have come out at work as a trans man. I have helped to design and run…
This matters to me because I believe in equal rights for members of the trans community
This matters to me because I believe in equal rights for members of the trans community. I have engaged in debate, done research to back my statements, and defended trans people. I have been harassed, declared ‘gay’, and insulted. Kit, Writer, Canada
This matters to me because poopoo peepee
This matters to me because poopoo peepee. I have shidded my pants. I have been ridiculed for shidding my pants. Karen, Gen Crit Mom
This represents a huge problem for modern feminism unless we determine to move forward in solidarity with ALL women, cis AND trans
Because abuse of trans rights is abuse of human rights. The attempted imposition of hateful gender ideology by so-called ‘gender critics’ represents thinly-veiled bigotry and a sustained attack on scientific consensus, in defiance of all data, across multiple academic disciplines. No structural basis has yet been established for discriminatory language and practices employed. This represents…
I tried to tell people the truth
Stop lying about why your contract was not renewed, we know the truth. I tried to tell people the truth, Liar Maya. I have been stalked on Twitter and spammed screenshots of a gruesome torture by a deranged TERF. Graham L, I will talk for the women, Divorced
Those actions don’t belong in a decent humane society
Because I am a total clown who can’t keep my nasty bigoted views to myself. Been a total knob to trans women all the time. Made up nonsense shite to create a climate of fear against one of the most vulnerable groups in society, and tried to masquerade it as an honourable crusade for human…
The struggle for trans men is different but caused by many of the same prejudices
It matters to me that we, as feminists, stand up for our trans sisters, and acknowledge that the struggle for trans men is different but caused by many of the same prejudices. It matters because to do anything else would be to deny then the rights we take for granted. I have donated to trans support fund…
I’ve tried to show kindness to people who actually seem hurt or misguided about trans people
This matters to me because trans people are human beings who deserve compassion. I’ve tried to show kindness to people who actually seem hurt or misguided about trans people. Not really experienced any negative consequences, most people seem to think trans humans deserve rights just like everyone else. Pooplord, pronouns in bio
Trans people are people too
This matters to me because trans people are people too. I have tried to support trans people any way I can. TRANS RIGHTS. Trans rights are human rights. TRANS RIGHTS
Like cis women, I just want to go to the bathroom
Like cis women, I just want to go to the bathroom. To pee. Without being harassed. Without being scared for my life. Due to suicide and murder, black trans women have a shockingly low life expectancy. All trans people just want to be treated as people. Your work, beliefs, and followers have made me want…
Trans rights are human rights
Trans rights are human rights. Trans rights are human rights. Trans rights are human rights Trans rights are human rights. Trans rights are human rights
Trans rights are human rights
Trans rights are human rights. I’ve reached out to transphobes for an open discussion about why their rhetorics are harmful and how they contradict modern medical consensus. Trans Rights
Terfery is hate speech
Terfery is hate speech. Called out hate speech and had my Twitter account reported for it. You really should get a life and find something better to do than harass trans people. Feminism Appropriating Reactionary Transphobe
Most people think mocking TERFs is pretty funny and a good use of leisure time
Trans rights are human rights. Trans people are people. I’ve mocked TERFs a lot. No negative consequences, most people think mocking TERFs is pretty funny and a good use of leisure time. Yeahnah. Not a twat
No one has ever said, or will ever say probably, that sex doesn’t matter
This matters to me because I’m trans and I would like to believe that I, as an individual, have the ability to know who I am. None of us are saying that sex doesn’t exist. We know it does. When people go to the doctor, they can still go by their name (as in not…
I simply don’t see this as anyone’s business other than the individuals themselves
I simply don’t see this as anyone’s business other than the individuals themselves. As soon as they say they are hurting because of certain celebrities spewing out hatred, I feel compelled to fight alongside them and to show solidarity. I have spoken against Jk Rowling, and discussed the issue with friends who may have differing…
Fragile McCis
Here’s a thing that happened to one of my friends. I was there. Basically, we were walking down the sidewalk, talking about something meaningless. I think it had to do with a movie. Then this bus screeches up, stops next to us, and a bunch of people with “Down with Cis” shirts climbed out and…
Fuck off and suck a hippo’s ass
Trans rights are human rights. The gender police should MIND THEIR OWN FUCKING BUSINESS. I have been disgusted at the way you call yourselves anything by GIGANTIC ASSHOLES. Sad, Mean, Reductionist, Pseudo-Feminists is what you are and you’re pathetic. Fuck off and suck a hippo’s ass. TRANS RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS YOU FUCKING TWATS! Fuck…
The false narrative that trans women are men (very obviously they are not)
I care about human rights and will fight every step of the way to ensure that the human rights of trans people are not threatened or rolled back; this includes the human right to self-recognition, legal recognition, protection from sex discrimination and ensuring that trans women are correctly and fully protected in law the same…
I have had to hide who I was to get jobs and do well in school
This matters to me because you are a bully and should be ashamed of yourself. I have lived as a trans person in spite of people like you who have made it their mission to rid the world of us. I have lost almost my entire family. I have had to hide who I was…
I myself have in the last few years come to identify as nonbinary so I want all those good things for myself
When I went to college, I met people who were trans and realized that was a normal part of human experience and diversity. I love my trans friends and want them to have safety and dignity and equal treatment. In addition, I myself have in the last few years come to identify as nonbinary so…
The rights of trans people are important and they are done a disservice by false narratives
I care because the rights of trans people are important and they are done a disservice by false narratives. I have made sure to be open and honest during debates. I have been abused online because of it. Jackie, Trans Rights Activist
The Gender Dissidents Survey 